Thursday 12 November 2015

Lemon Meringue Pie Toastie

toastie that tastes like lemon meringue pie filled with biscuit spread, lemon curd and marshmallow creme

This is such an easy recipe, yet so tasty I can’t believe I hadn’t thought of it before!

I really have to thank Cheese Postie, from my recent post who deliver creative toasties like these through your letter box. I was sent a strawberry shortcake flavour cheese toastie, using cookie butter and strawberry jam, plus mascarpone. I loved the flavours and it got me to thinking.

What if I used cookie butter, AKA Biscoff, AKA Speculoos, lemon curd and marshmallowy fluffy stuff? Surely this would taste just like a lemon meringue pie? I had to find out…

toastie that tastes like lemon meringue pie filled with biscuit spread, lemon curd and marshmallow creme

I bought a loaf of white bread, and the above ingredients and started to assemble. I slathered one bit of bread with the Biscoff, one side with lemon curd and then spread the mallow crème on top of the biscoff.  I sandwiched the two bits of bread together and lightly coated the outsides of the bread with some butter.

toastie that tastes like lemon meringue pie filled with biscuit spread, lemon curd and marshmallow creme

At this point you could use a toastie machine, a panini press or as I did, one of those toaster bags. I popped my sandwich in the baggy and popped it in the toaster. Mines did catch a bit on one edge (think my toaster is on the fritz!),  but if using a toastie machine this won’t happen.

This resulting toastie has to be left for a minute or two, as the sugar contents do heat up to near-volcanic temperatures, but once it is an edible warmth, the taste is incredible. You get the biscuit base of the pie from the Biscoff, the lemon hit from the curd and the mallow meringue in the middle. Great fun to try and enjoy!

print recipe

Lemon Meringue Pie Toastie
A toasted sandwich that tastes like a Lemon Meringue Pie
  • 2 Slices bread (any type)
  • 1-2 Teaspoons Biscuit Spread (such as Biscoff)
  • 1-2 Teaspoons Lemon Curd
  • 1-2 Teaspoons Marshmallow Creme (such as Fluff)
  • 1-2 Teaspoons Butter (or other spread)
Spread one slice of bread with the biscuit spread.Spread the other slice of bread with the lemon curd.Spread the marshmallow crème on top of the biscuit spread and sandwich the two slices of bread together.Spread the outside of each side of the sandwich with the butter or spread.Place in a toaster bag and toast on medium setting, or place in a toastie machine.Remove once the outside of the sandwich is golden brown.Allow to cool for a few minutes before slicing in half.Enjoy!
Prep time: Cook time: Total time: Yield: 1 sandwich

I am entering this toastie into this month’s Club Sandwich hosted alternately by myself and this month my pal Kevin at The Crafty Larder. If this inspires you, we’d love to see other crazy sarnie concoctions, so please join in!


  1. I love this idea, how inventive nom. x

  2. This is filthy... But I love it...

  3. This is genius Stuart! Need to try out this sweet toastie thing.

  4. I'm interested, but at the same time frightened and a little repulsed in equal measures.....I need to ponder sweet toasties....I'm sure I will reach acceptance!


Thanks for leaving your comments. I love your feedback and really do appreciate it.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.